Which Wine Club is Right for You?
Wine Club Reviews & Ratings

WSJ Wine 12-Bottle vs. 15-Bottle Offers

WSJ Wine Logo 120x60WSJ Wine Club from The Wall Street Journal has two different offers

  1. 12 bottles with free gift
  2. 15 bottles

So what’s the difference? Let’s compare them:

Feature12-Bottle Offer15-Bottle Offer
Bottles of Wine1215
Types of WineRed
White
Mixed
Red
White
Mixed
Value$189.99$239.99
Initial Cost$69.99$69.99
Savings$120.00$170.00
Initial Cost / Bottle$5.83$4.67
Free giftLever-action corkscrew setNone
Ongoing cost$149.99$149.99
Ongoing bottles1212
Ongoing cost / bottle$12.50$12.50

As you can see, the difference in the two offers lies only in the initial offer: choose either 12 bottles and a free gift, or 15 bottles of wine.

Personally, I’m not a fan of fancy corkscrews and prefer a simple waiters key (see How to open a wine bottle with a “waiter’s key”) and therefore I’d choose the 15 bottle offer, but if you were giving this as a gift, the corkscrew may be a welcome addition to the package.

The following two tabs change content below.
Eric is based in Buffalo, NY - near the Niagara Wine Trail. He's a fan of Pinot Noir, but appreciates any good wine. Here at the Wine Club Group, Eric is the programmer who makes the site work. He also does video reviews of wine clubs and individual wines.

Latest posts by Eric Nagel (see all)

If you have a comment or question, ask us here: